The Verge·Apr 14, 2026

🚨Google's Data Sharing Practices Under Fire from EFF

EFF Asks California and New York to Investigate Google

TL;DR

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) is asking California and New York to investigate Google's policy of giving user data to law enforcement without notifying users. This comes after an incident where a user found out their personal email was subpoenaed by the Department of Homeland Security.

Google has promised users that it will notify them before handing over their personal data to law enforcement, but failed to do so in the case of Amandla Thomas-Johnson. The EFF alleges that this is not an isolated incident and that Google has likely violated its promise numerous other times over the years. This raises concerns for developers who rely on Google services for their projects. If Google's policy is found to be in violation, it could lead to changes in how companies handle user data and government requests. The EFF is seeking injunctive relief, including civil penalties of up to $2,500 per violation in California.

Google's Data Sharing Practices Under Fire from EFF

Key Points

1

Google's policy allows for administrative subpoenas like the one DHS issued for Thomas-Johnson's, which are not approved by a judge.

2

Companies can refuse to comply with these subpoenas and face no repercussions for doing so.

3

The EFF is asking California and New York to investigate Google's practices and seeks injunctive relief, including civil penalties of up to $2,500 per violation in California.

Why It Matters

For developers who rely on Google services for their projects, this raises concerns about data security and the potential for government overreach. If Google's policy is found to be in violation, it could lead to changes in how companies handle user data and government requests.

GoogleEFFuser data sharinglaw enforcementgovernment requests

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does this matter?

For developers who rely on Google services for their projects, this raises concerns about data security and the potential for government overreach. If Google's policy is found to be in violation, it could lead to changes in how companies handle user data and government requests.

What happened?

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) is asking California and New York to investigate Google's policy of giving user data to law enforcement without notifying users. This comes after an incident where a user found out their personal email was subpoenaed by the Department of Homeland Security.

Comments

Subscribe to join the conversation...

Be the first to comment

Enjoyed this article?

Get the top stories delivered to your inbox every morning. Free.