🚀NASA and SpaceX Dispute Starship Moon Landing Launch Estimates
NASA and SpaceX clash over Starship moon landing launch numbers
TL;DR
NASA's ASAP estimates 22 launches for Starship moon landings, while Elon Musk counters with 6 to 8. The debate centers on refueling needs and historical comparisons to Apollo's Lunar Module.
NASA's Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel (ASAP) estimates that 22 launches of SpaceX's Starship are needed to support a moon landing under the Artemis program. However, Elon Musk disputes this, suggesting the actual number will be closer to 6 to 8 launches. The discrepancy hinges on the need for in-space refueling, a requirement unique to Starship due to its cryogenic propellants, unlike Apollo's hypergolic propellants. This debate underscores the ambitious nature of the Artemis program and SpaceX's plans to phase out Falcon rockets and Dragon spacecraft, leaving Starliner as the sole commercial crew option for the ISS.
Key Points
NASA's ASAP estimates 22 launches for Starship moon landings, citing refueling needs.
Elon Musk counters ASAP's estimate, suggesting 6 to 8 launches are sufficient.
Apollo's Lunar Module used hypergolic propellants, avoiding the need for in-space refueling.
SpaceX has completed one Starship test flight to orbit, with more to follow.
NASA seeks US alternatives to Russian spacecraft for crew and cargo transport.
Why It Matters
The debate over launch estimates impacts the feasibility and timeline of the Artemis program. If ASAP's estimate is accurate, the logistical and financial burden could be significantly higher. For teams relying on Starship for future missions, understanding these discrepancies is crucial for planning and resource allocation.
Comments
Be the first to comment
Enjoyed this article?
Get it daily. 7am. Free. Reads in 5 minutes.
Join 3,567 builders reading daily.