🦇Philosopher Thomas Nagel Wins $1M Berggruen Prize for Bat Consciousness Work
Your chatbot isn't conscious, and that matters
TL;DR
The philosopher behind 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?' won the $1 million Berggruen Prize. He now argues AI models aren't conscious, can only simulate morality, and that treating them as minds is unhealthy. Worth reading before your next AI-driven design debate.
The author of 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?' just collected the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture, and his latest take on AI is blunt: the models aren't conscious. The paper he wrote more than 50 years ago became a classic, and the prize honors work that reshapes how humans understand themselves in a fast-changing world. Past winners include Peter Singer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Why should you care? Because the author says large language models have changed how he thinks, and he's pushing back on how people talk about these systems. His view is that AI produces language, but language alone isn't a natural sign of consciousness. Treating chatbots as minds, he argues, can be unhealthy, and it may quietly reduce the hard intellectual work people are willing to do themselves. The specifics matter. He grants that consciousness could exist elsewhere in the universe, but only in organisms with something analogous to a nervous system, and he doesn't think data centers qualify. He also says AI can simulate moral reasoning and philosophical essays without holding real moral beliefs. Whether a physical substrate is required for consciousness remains the open question he keeps returning to.

Key Points
The Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture carries a $1 million award and is given annually to an individual whose ideas profoundly shape human self-understanding in a rapidly changing world.
Keep reading — it's free
Enter your email to keep reading — plus the best of AI & tech, daily. Free, forever.
Already a member? Sign in
Comments
Be the first to comment